Dear Teacher, I have been advised to
never tell a professional anything about their business, and usually I abide by that
advice, but in the past few years there has been a movement within our schools that has
grown a life of its own. A movement to which I am so totally opposed that I am compelled
to speak out. My educational qualifications offer me no standing as an authority on the
subject, but even in this age of "experts", experience and concern must still
count for something. I am not a teacher, but have enjoyed mentoring youth in technical
matters for over forty years. When I was in school I lived the life of the youths that I
am writing on the behalf of, and have slowly come to the realization that something can
and must be done about their situation. The subject I am addressing is Attention Deficit
Disorder and the multiple learning disabilities that are often diagnosed in addition to
the typical symptoms of ADD. I fully recognize that there is a serious problem.Youth who are labeled as having ADD and the modern classroom
environment are completely incompatible. The list of incompatibilities is quite long. Head
strong, often a loner, questions authority, excessive curiosity, has an internal
compulsion for excitement, dislikes sitting still for long periods, gives the impression
of being lazy, a procrastinator, and maybe even impudent. Often, in elementary school,
these youth have considerable trouble with reading, spelling and math. Simply said, these
youths are somehow very different from their well behaved, easy to teach
classroom-orientated peers. My message to teachers is that, as frustrating as they can be,
as much distraction as they can cause in the classroom, and as much difficulty as they
seem to have in learning, there is nothing at all wrong with them. They don't suffer from
some mysterious malady, nor do they have brain defects, chemical imbalances or many of the
other "guessed at" reasons for their actions. They are however, definitely
different, and they are different in many different ways. They are not only late to mature
socially but their ability to handle symbols such as those used in reading and math is
often late to mature. (Some times these abilities will not mature to the level of a first
grade student until as late as their third grade in school). Trying to make them read
before the ability has matured is like trying to get a young child to chew a chunk of good
steak before they have cut their first set of teeth. They may be able to go through the
motions of the required activity, but they will not be very good at it, and may even grow
a life-long hatred for being forced into a particular study before God has gotten around
to furnishing them with the required equipment.
ADD labeled youth seem to have about ten times the
level of curiosity of the average youth. They simply can't pass up looking into a hole in
the ground, watching a unique piece of road machinery or going through every drawer,
cupboard and closet where ever they are. They pickup and closely examine all manner of
things that the average youth takes for granted and never even notices. Most people have
never considered that the first three years of conventional school is a continuing process
designed to psychologically numb a youths curiosity to the point where they can sit
disinterestedly at their desk regardless of what is going on outside, or in the hall.
Squashing curiosity is an invisible and unquestioned "socialization process"
that is assumed to benefit the student, the school and the parents because they will all
profit from a "well mannered", "attentive" youth. But when a youth
starts out with a much higher than normal level of curiosity, standard psychological
tactics fail to bring their curiosity into line, and by the third grade the youth and
their teachers often end up in an adversarial role. Some folks assume that the youth is
acting that way because of some desire on their part "be bad", and they are
punished accordingly.
My message is that there is a growing body of
evidence that these youth are not only different, but that they are in reality, a
"different breed" of human kind. They are genetically pre-disposed and mentally
hard wired for what we call the "Edison trait". Some of the Edison trait
features are; 1) High levels of curiosity 2) Late in developing symbol and social maturity
3) Early in developing maturity of their extraordinary conceptual thinking skills
(unfortunately these conceptual thinking skills are neither taught to, nor measured, in
conventional schools) 4) They seem to search out excitement 5) They are dedicated
adventurers/explorers 6) They tend to be hard headed, I'll do it myself types 7) In the
extreme, these youth live in a forty-eight hour window that travels through time with
them. (E.g., they have no future and no past and seem incapable of working on a long term
assignment until it is within their forty-eight hour window of necessity). For some
professions this is a highly desirable trait. Note: Somewhere between twenty and
twenty-five years of age their sense of future and past will mature and they will start
planning their lives. 8) Because of their unusual curiosity they often appear to be easily
distracted by extraneous sources. I love the stories they tell of watching bugs crawling
on the ceilings of their classrooms. 9) They have little appreciation of, or use for,
conventional filing systems. They are what we call "piling people" as opposed to
"filing people". They sort things by logical relationships as opposed to
conventional schemes, and use highly accurate mental images to remember where something is
piled. 10) A large percent or these youths have a great deal of trouble with rote memory
of dates, names, and numbers. On the other hand, they have great memories for logically
related data once they see the underlying logic. Such things as large electrical schematic
drawings and engine layouts are easy for them to remember once they have mapped out the
connectedness between the parts and their function. Those youth that are blesses with both
rote and conceptual memory have the best of both worlds and do well in school even though
they drive their teachers crazy. This is just a sample of some of the more obvious traits
of these remarkable youth, there are many additional, and more subtle, differences in
their way of thinking and their approach to life.
We believe that the ADD traits are observable in
nearly thirty percent of the current youth population. Some youth seem to have more of the
traits and in some of these, their traits seem to be much stronger and more pronounced.
The ones who fall into the more and stronger group (the top five percent or so) are
singled out as having ADD. The others are able to hide their differences (we call this
accommodation) well enough that they eventually get through school with only minor
skirmishes. We also believe that these remarkable youth are genetically designed to be
exactly the way they are and they are just as incapable of being taught to change their
ways as a zebra is of being able to change its stripes in order to impersonate a horse.
What most teachers and medical professionals fail to appreciate is that these youth belong
to a exclusive minority of explorers, inventors, engineers and entrepreneurs that have
changed the paradigms that we all live by. Some of these minorities names are Tom Edison,
Henry Ford, and Albert Einstein. Each of these remarkable men shared the so called ADD
characteristics with these kids. The very traits that their parents, schools and society
dislike so much, and are trying to change, are at the seat of their curiosity, creativity
and hard headed approach to life. These traits are the absolutely necessary ones that are
used in bolstering and sustaining their curiosity driven lifestyle.
Recently we have found preliminary evidence which
indicates that maintaining a strong and active curiosity is also extremely important to
their maintaining good mental health. The same traits that cause so much trouble in the
classroom are the ones that lead them toward questioning everything and accepting almost
nothing on face value. They are also the traits that open their minds to new thoughts and
processes and leave them with little respect for tradition and blind obedience to
authority. Minds such as these are the ones that have consistently broken through the
culturally generated, imaginary, shells of "it can't be done", and have
dramatically changed our world from cave dwellings to skyscrapers.
I strongly suggest that the kids who are being
castigated as having behavior problems due to ADD are the progeny of the labeled political
and social misfits that were pushed out of Europe and who built America into the strong,
vibrant, creative country that we all enjoy today. Unless we recognize these creative,
resourceful, hardheaded youth for the extraordinary values that they possess, and develop
a different kind of school that teaches to their strengths instead of struggling with
their weaknesses, we will continue killing the goose that laid the golden egg for our
society. Project Lab is just one of many efforts world wide to design a learning
environment for these youth. Project Lab is a continuing experiment in developing a
curriculum and learning environment that will combine the right combination of ingredients
for enhancing the exciting traits that these very special youth possess. We consistently
observe youth who in their regular class have a reputation of not being able to "stay
on task", but who will diligently work for hours while solving some problem that is
of current interest to them. We have found that they can learn almost anything, (excluding
the memorizing of logically unrelated names, dates, and numbers) when the subject is
related to an internal interest of theirs. If there is magic in Project Lab, it is that we
believe in self-directed-learning and have faith that these youth are entirely capable of
teaching themselves everything up through the highest of college level courses. They will
not learn the material in the same order, or even in the same way, that you or I did, but
through a process of hit and miss, start and stop, back and fourth, try and fail, size and
fit, feel and experience, they eventually master anything that they can visualize.
They do however, need help in accomplishing their
goals. In the early stages of their introduction to self-directed-learning, if their level
of frustration is allowed to become to high, they will break off the direction they were
going and start out on a different path, usually on a totally different subject. It is the
function of the Project Lab's Advisors (mentors) to grease their path by answering their
questions, helping locate needed information, tools and supplies (in a timely manner) and
having a genuine interest in the youths efforts and accomplishments. We have found that it
is extremely important that a youth be allowed to fail. The best scientists fail over
ninety-five percent of the time and are fully aware that failure is their best friend and
most reliable teacher. All of what is known as "good engineering" is based
solidly on the observation of failure and then finding ways of overcoming the problems
that the failure has made visible. Nowhere in conventional schooling is failure considered
a virtue but is instead considered a grave personal defeat. Helping youth overcome their
society taught fear of failure is one of our toughest jobs.
We have only touched on a few subjects but I am sure
that you have gotten the idea. Teachers are always welcome at Project Lab, but they
usually feel so uncomfortable that they soon leave. There is no regimented arrangement of
youth sitting in neat rows. There is no regulation as to who can talk or whistle. There is
no starting time or quitting time. The youth are in charge and this is their place for
having fun. It took us years to discover that the most fun thing that they can experience
is their "process of self-directed-learning". Adults who are unaccustomed to
such free wheeling classrooms find it impossible to believe that any education is actually
taking place. The funny thing is that the youth are also unawares of learning anything.
They are having the best time in their lives. It is only when they go on to college that
they discover how much more they know about "things" than most of their
classmates who have only been exposed to the "approved" body of knowledge. When
they get out of college and into the work place they find out that they can easily
accomplish tasks that the other employees are hopelessly lost at.
We have never had to "control the group".
It sort of builds up to, and cycles about, a self regulating point where creativity is
maximized. It takes about an hour to reach this level and few youth are ready to leave
when the time comes that they must. The times when we have had trouble at Project Lab have
almost always been when someone felt called upon to "teach" something in the
conventional manner. Although these youth are dedicated learners, the most tedious moments
of their lives are when they are confronted with someone that is dedicated to teach them
something for which they see little value in their current lives.
It takes a year or more for Project Lab Advisors and
the youth to get to know each other well enough that the advisors are significantly able
to affect the direction of their youth's learning process. At that point students can be
directed into math and English and other related subjects. To the youth's amazement, they
find that they also enjoy learning these subjects. This is a strange world, but there are
few stranger or more precious commodities than the youth who are being labeled as having
something called ADD. We must find ways to protect these youth from the mind numbing
effects of conventional show-and-tell, pencil-and-paper education. It has been our
observation that the typical youth who has been labeled as having ADD and who has
graduated from college but has not been in a program that brought out their remarkable
potential, often accepts work at a level far below their capabilities. I can only assume
that it is from their years of feeling "somehow different" that results in their
not having the self image required to search out premium employment.
